The first time I got bareback was with a guy I had hooked up with a bunch of times before, mostly for oral, but we did anal with a condom before.
Anyway he came over my place and we exchanged oral a couple of times making each other really hard and he ate my ass which drives me crazy. After he ate my ass he got up between my legs and told me he wanted to tease my ass with his cock a little bit. Now having hooked up quite a few times before I had no reason to think he'd try anything, but after he teased my tight hole for a few seconds he pushed forward and shoved his cock balls deep into my ass. I remember my eyes popping open when I realized what he had just done and that his cock was in me raw, and then I just moaned and told him to fuck me. The rest of the night we fucked bb I even took him ass to mouth and rode him. The only thing that disappointed me was that he didn't breed my hole when he came, he gave me a facial instead, but I did suck his cock clean and ate all the cum from my face as well.
That was my first time, it wasn't planned but it was hot. What about yours?